South Naples · Collier County, FL
📞 (239) 877-4646
Florida REALTOR® · License SL3504588 ·Realty ONE Group MVP · The Nicholas Nolan Team ·Independent Lely Resort resource ·📞 (239) 877-4646
Condos & Golf Villas · Lely Resort

Mystic Greens

Players Club: Optional

Condo and coach units strung along the Flamingo course, with a wide range of sizes — from compact to surprisingly roomy.

The overview

About Mystic Greens

Mystic Greens lets you pick your size without changing your address: condo and coach units run from a compact 1,385 to a roomy 2,337 square feet, all along the Flamingo course. The buildings date roughly 1992–2000, and some units include two-car garages.

A community pool serves the neighborhood, and Players Club membership is optional — a flexible, established choice.

Figures are approximate, compiled from MLS and public/association sources, and change without notice. Confirm current dues, rules, and covenant status for any specific home before relying on them — or ask me.

Quick facts

Property typeCondos & coach homes
Build years1992–2000
BuilderMultiple builders
Typical size~1,385–2,337 sq ft
Bedrooms2–3
Homes / units~96
ViewsGolf (Flamingo), lake
Community amenitiesCommunity pool
Players ClubOptional
HOA (approx.)~$1,621/quarter — verify
Rentals30-day minimum, ~3 leases/yr
PetsAllowed with approval
The market

What homes cost in Mystic Greens

1
active listing
$619K
active price range
$312K
median sold (all-time)
$149
median $/sq ft (all-time)

Drawn from this community’s recorded MLS sales; the active snapshot is June 2026 and changes constantly. Want live, exact numbers and what’s available right now? Ask for a current Mystic Greens report. Live MLS listings open on our team’s search site.

Is it right for you?

Living in Mystic Greens

What buyers love

  • ✓ Wide range of sizes & prices
  • ✓ Some homes with two-car garages
  • ✓ Optional Players Club
  • ✓ Community pool

Worth knowing

  • • Higher quarterly dues
  • • 1990s–2000s construction
  • • Optional club = amenities not bundled

Players Club & Spa: Mystic Greens is on the Optional list — membership is available but not required. See what the Players Club costs, the cost-of-ownership guide, and Players Club amenities.

Resort living

Golf & the Players Club & Spa

Players Club & Spa membership is optional in Mystic Greens — add full resort access if you want it, or skip the cost if you don’t.

In Mystic Greens itself: Community pool.

Local market intelligence

The data on Mystic Greens

Homes in Mystic Greens take a little longer to sell (~75 days), at about 95% of list price (~5% negotiating room). At ~2.3 months of supply, it's tight, seller-friendly supply.

75 days
median time to sell
95%
of list price received
$250
median $/sq ft (recent)
$545K
median sold (recent)
~5/yr
homes sold
~2.3 mo
months of supply

Based on 17 recorded sales (2023–2026) plus older history; figures are approximate and change constantly.

Age & what to check

Home age~28 years (built 1998)
A/CPast typical service life — many have been replaced; verify the date and condition.
Water heaterPast typical life — likely replaced at least once; verify.
RoofAt or near the end of typical underlayment life — verify replacement (key for insurance).
Insurance & codePre-2002 construction — get a wind-mitigation inspection; roof and opening updates can sharply lower premiums.

What agents highlight

Across recent Mystic Greens listings, agents most often highlight turnkey-furnished options, preserve/privacy, and outdoor living.

Before closing: ask for Mystic Greens’s latest budget, reserve study, and any planned special assessments — and confirm the Players Club covenant on the exact home.

Good to know

Mystic Greens FAQs

Is Players Club membership required in Mystic Greens?

No — it's optional. Mystic Greens carries the Non-Amenities Covenant, so you can join the Players Club & Spa for full resort access or skip it to save the cost. Verify the covenant on any specific home.

How much does the Players Club & Spa cost in Mystic Greens?

If you choose to join (it's optional in Mystic Greens), the Players Club & Spa runs about a $10,000 refundable deposit plus roughly $6,400 a year (+6% tax). Skip it and you avoid that cost entirely. Figures change — confirm current rates with the Club.

What are the HOA fees in Mystic Greens?

Roughly ~$1,621/quarter — verify. HOA dues typically cover community maintenance and common areas (often landscaping), but usually do not include Players Club dues. Confirm the current amount and exactly what's covered for the specific home.

Can you rent out a home in Mystic Greens? What are the leasing rules?

In Mystic Greens, the association allows 30-day minimum, ~3 leases/yr. That sets the minimum lease length and how many times per year you can lease — important for rental or seasonal use. Rules change, so confirm the current limits for the exact home.

Are pets allowed in Mystic Greens?

Yes — in Mystic Greens, pets are allowed with approval. The association sets the specifics (number, size, and sometimes breed), and rules change — confirm the current pet policy for the exact home.

Does Mystic Greens have its own pool or clubhouse?

Yes. Mystic Greens has its own community pool, on top of the resort-wide Players Club & Spa and Lely's three golf courses.

How far is Mystic Greens from the Players Club & Spa?

The Players Club & Spa is centrally located within Lely Resort, so from Mystic Greens it's a few minutes by car or golf cart. Most of the community is within roughly a mile or two of the club.

How much do homes cost in Mystic Greens?

Recent listings in Mystic Greens have ranged about $619K, with a median sold price near $312K (about $149/sq ft). Inventory is limited and changes constantly — ask for a live Mystic Greens report.

Is Mystic Greens a 55+ or age-restricted community?

No. Mystic Greens, like all of Lely Resort, is an all-ages community — it is not age-restricted. Homes here serve full-time, seasonal, and rental use.

How fast do homes sell in Mystic Greens, and is there room to negotiate?

Recently, Mystic Greens homes have sold in a median of 75 days at about 95% of list price — roughly 5% negotiating room. With ~2.3 months of supply, it's a seller's market. These numbers shift constantly, so ask me for this week's read before you make a move.

How old are homes in Mystic Greens, and what should I inspect?

Mystic Greens homes date to 1998 (about 28 years old). At that age, look closely at the A/C (12–15-yr life), water heater (10–12-yr), and roof, and ask for the permit history.

Will home insurance be expensive in Mystic Greens?

Budget carefully. Mystic Greens predates the 2002 Florida Building Code, so get a wind-mitigation inspection — updated roofs and impact openings can sharply lower premiums.

Schools

Schools near Mystic Greens

Like the rest of Lely Resort, Mystic Greens sits in South Naples’ 34113 area and is served by Collier County Public Schools, an A-rated district. The public schools most often associated with Lely Resort are Lely Elementary, Manatee Middle and Lely High School — but attendance zones change, so confirm the current assignment for the exact address. Our schools near Lely Resort guide has recent ratings, private-school options and how to verify zoning.

A day here: morning coffee looking out over the Flamingo course, laps at the community pool, and an afternoon round on a public course you never had to join. Could you see yourself here?

Talk to a local specialist

Thinking about Mystic Greens?

I’ll send current Mystic Greens listings, the real dues and membership picture for the exact home, and honest pros and cons. No pressure.

  • ✓ Independent — not paid by the developer
  • ✓ Live MLS data for Mystic Greens
  • ✓ Florida REALTOR® SL3504588

By submitting, you agree to be contacted by Nicholas Nolan, Realty ONE Group MVP. We never share your info. Privacy.

Talk to Nick(239) 877-4646